A certificate of insurance for subcontractors is a short summary of your policy, shown to a party that is not on it, such as a general contractor or a city. It proves a policy exists but adds no coverage, and the name on its holder line gains no rights under the policy.
What the form reports to whoever asks for it
A certificate reports a policy that already exists. New Jersey’s Department of Banking and Insurance says certificates “are used in many commercial contexts as proof that a policy of insurance is in effect, and usually summarize the essential terms, conditions and duration of the policy.” The same bulletin says the use of certificates is “particularly prevalent to provide proof of liability and workers’ compensation coverages.”
The California Department of Insurance describes what a homeowner should see on one. It tells homeowners to ask for a certificate “that shows the name of the insurance company, policy number, and policy limits the contractor carries.” The insurer, the policy number and the limits are what a reader can use to check it; the figures themselves belong to your policy, not to this page.
Indiana’s Department of Insurance calls a certificate a “courtesy summary of the terms of an insurance policy on the day it is issued.” The form shows the day it was made, so a sub whose policy changes mid-project should ask the agent for a fresh certificate.
What a certificate does not do
A certificate cannot enlarge the policy. Rhode Island’s Certificates of Insurance Model Act says a certificate “is not a policy of insurance and does not affirmatively or negatively amend, extend, or alter the coverage afforded by the policy to which the certificate of insurance makes reference.” It adds that a certificate “shall not confer to any person new or additional rights beyond what the referenced policy of insurance expressly provides.”
Connecticut’s Insurance Department sets out what that leaves the person who holds one without. The department says that, generally, a certificate “confers no rights or benefits upon the third party certificate holder to the underlying insurance stated in the certificate”, and the department says it does not make the holder an additional insured. That status takes an endorsement, or being named an insured under the policy’s terms.
Montana’s version of the model act goes at the contract. A certificate “may not warrant that the policy of insurance referenced in the certificate complies with the insurance or indemnification requirements of a contract,” and a contract number or description on it does not warrant compliance, the statute adds. The certificate can be accurate and the policy can still fall short of what the subcontract asks.
What the policy covers or excludes for spray foam, fiberglass or blown-in work is read from the policy itself, not from the summary. The spray foam and fiberglass and blown-in service pages and the general liability coverage page describe the coverage in general.
The certificate holder line and who belongs on it
The holder is whoever asked for proof. Connecticut’s bulletin describes the holder as “a company or individual who is not a party to the insurance policy”. On an insulation job that is the general contractor in a subcontract, or the city in a registration or permit.
The holder box is a name field, not a rights field. The Texas Department of Insurance FAQ takes up a holder that wants its officers, employees, subsidiaries and assigns listed in that box. The answer is that a holder may not use the box to “imply or confer any new or additional rights beyond what the policy or any executed endorsement of insurance provides.”
Cancellation notice shows the same limit. Oregon’s Division of Financial Regulation says a contract may require notice of cancellation with a specific number of days’ notice, while the certificate can say only that the insurer will deliver notice “in accordance with policy provisions”. Texas’s department adds that a notice statement is acceptable on a Texas certificate “as long as the provision mirrors the requirements in the insurance policy.”
Where the holder line ends and the endorsement begins
General contractors ask for more than a holder line, and the certificate has a limit there. The Texas Department of Insurance says that when the policy holds just a blanket endorsement for additional insureds and nothing naming the holder, the certificate cannot list the holder as additional insured, though it “can state that the policy contains a Blanket Additional Insured endorsement.” The department makes the same point for waivers of subrogation.
On a Texas risk, the boxes on the ACORD form follow the policy. In the Texas department’s words, check the additional insured box “if the policy includes an endorsement that names the certificate holder as an additional insured.” The department ties the box to the endorsement, not to the request.
How the endorsements work, ongoing and completed, with waivers, has its own post: Additional Insured Endorsement: Ongoing, Completed, Waivers.
Real-World Scenario: An insulation crew blowing cellulose into attics for a remodeling contractor hears from the remodeler and from the city in the same week. The remodeler wants a certificate naming it as holder, and wants the policy to cover it as an added party and waive recovery against it. The city wants a certificate naming the city as holder before it releases a permit. The agent can show each holder line on a certificate from the policy as it stands. The additional insured status and the waiver cannot appear until the policy carries the endorsements, so the office sends the subcontract pages to the agent before the first truck rolls.
What a general contractor can have the certificate say
The Texas Department of Insurance’s FAQ answers questions about what a certificate holder may ask a certificate to say, and the answers show where the line sits for a Texas risk. A certificate “may not contain a reference to a legal or insurance requirement contained in a contract other than the underlying contract of insurance, including a contract for construction or services.” A contract or job number can sit on it for identification only.
For a Texas risk, the department says a supplemental questionnaire in addition to the certificate, or an affidavit about insurance requirements in connection with a contract, is not allowed, because the Texas certificate chapter permits only approved certificates. Instead, the department says “You may show the relevant policy language to the certificate holder.” A request that the certificate say the policy has no limitations or exclusions for residential construction gets the answer that “A certificate cannot say anything that is not the same as what is stated in the insurance policy.”
None of that leaves the general contractor without recourse. The department says “a certificate holder may ask the agent whether the policy contains specific language or a specific exclusion, or may request a copy of the policy.” Connecticut’s Insurance Department notes that some public or commercial organizations “may be requesting” certificates whose terms may conflict with the policy or the contract, and says certificates cannot be used to amend, expand or alter the policy. Indiana’s Department of Insurance tells producers faced with such demands to refer them “to the insurer with a request that these provisions be included in the insurance policy.”
For a sub, the practical reading is that a requirement the policy lacks is a conversation with the agent about the policy. The approved-form rule for Texas certificates is set out on the Texas state page.
Cities that put their own name on the holder line
Some cities ask for a certificate and name themselves as the holder. Each city below is on our state page for its state, and the words here are only what that city office’s own page says.
Texas: the City of El Paso’s registration sheet for general contractors lists a certificate covering general liability, and its note says the certificate “must specify City of El Paso as the Certificate Holder”.
Louisiana: Lake Charles’s license, bond and insurance page says contractors “furnish a certificate of public liability insurance”, and that “The City of Lake Charles is to be listed as a certificate holder.”
Nebraska: La Vista’s construction and tradesmen license application says “The Insurance Certificate must list the City of La Vista as a Certificate Holder.”
Read the city’s page for your own trade and permit type; each city above is limited to the page it quotes.
Workers’ compensation certificates at the permit counter
Other cities on our state pages ask for a workers’ compensation certificate, and some of them name the holder. Connecticut: Hartford’s Development Services lists a “Current Workers Comp Insurance Certificate (listing the City of Hartford as the Certificate Holder)” among the documents to submit with its building and trades application.
Missouri: Columbia’s Finance Department says “Proof of Workers’ Compensation Insurance, in the form of a Certificate of Insurance, must be provided by all construction industry businesses” that have employees, and that “The City of Columbia must be included as the certificate holder.”
Pennsylvania: Lancaster’s residential permit application asks whether the contractor carries workers’ compensation; on a yes, the contractor must provide a certificate “listing the City of Lancaster as the certificate holder”, and on a no, a notarized exemption form.
California: in a notice to contractors, Los Angeles’s building department cites the state Labor Code for showing a workers’ compensation certificate whenever a permit is issued, and says “The certificate holder must be the contractor’s state license board.” The same notice exempts applicants who have no employees from that step.
For a subcontracted crew’s own workers’ compensation proof and the payroll audit that follows it, see the post on subcontracted crews and the payroll audit.
Checking a certificate before a sub starts
A certificate is only as good as the policy behind it, and the regulators who write to homeowners describe confirming it. The California Department of Insurance says “You may contact the insurance company directly to verify information on the COI.” The Texas Department of Insurance tells consumers to “Call the companies listed to verify the coverage.” California also lists a contractor “unwilling to provide a certificate of insurance” as a warning sign.
These are consumer pages, and the contractor’s side is the mirror image. A general contractor that checks a sub’s certificate with the insurer named on it is taking the step those pages describe. The California page also says to keep certificates of insurance in the job file.
Asking your agent for the certificate you need
Send the request, not the summary of it. The holder’s exact name as the contract or the permit form words it, the job it is for, and any endorsement the contract requires all belong in the message to the agent. Connecticut’s bulletin says that providing a certificate that misrepresents policy terms “would violate Connecticut law”, so the request is for a certificate of the policy as it is.
When the request reaches past the policy, the endorsement comes first and the certificate second. Bring the subcontract’s insurance page along with a quote request, and read the bond and insurance post for the license and permit bonds that sit beside them. The license guide sets out which states license insulation work, before any certificate comes into it.