Coverage Explained

1099 Workers Comp: Subcontracted Crews and the Payroll Audit

A worker in work gloves pushing an insulation batt up between ceiling joists

1099 workers comp turns on state law. In the statutes quoted below, whether a subcontracted crew counts as the hiring contractor’s depends on the statute’s own conditions, not the tax form that paid it. Where a statute reaches the hiring contractor, an uninsured sub’s hurt worker can come to it, and the Massachusetts and Minnesota manuals can add the sub’s payroll to its policy when the premium is figured.

What the tax label settles and what it leaves open

The Internal Revenue Service writes its independent contractor page for tax treatment. It says “In determining whether the person providing service is an employee or an independent contractor, all information that provides evidence of the degree of control and independence must be considered”, and on taxes, “Generally, you do not have to withhold or pay any taxes on payments to independent contractors.” That is the tax side of the label on a sub’s payment.

The Department of Labor’s misclassification page states its test for wage law: “Misclassification occurs when an employer treats a worker who is an employee under the FLSA as an independent contractor.” The IRS and Labor Department pages are not workers’ compensation rules. For a worker injured at work, the Department’s workers’ compensation page points to the state: “Individuals injured on the job while employed by private companies or state and local government agencies should contact their state workers’ compensation board”. The rest of this post follows that pointer, state by state, in each statute’s own words. The workers’ compensation page covers what the policy pays.

Statutes that make the sub’s crew the original employer’s

Arizona’s workers’ compensation statute on original employers applies when an employer procures work from a contractor “over whose work the employer retains supervision or control”, and “the work is a part or process in the trade or business of the employer”. Then, in the statute’s words, “the contractors and the contractor’s employees, and any subcontractor and the subcontractor’s employees, are, within the meaning of this section, employees of the original employer”. Those conditions are in the statute’s text, and the sentence applies only when they are met. The Arizona page sets out the state’s wider rule.

Virginia’s statute on contractors and their subcontractors’ workers has two triggers. Subsection A applies when a person “undertakes to perform or execute any work which is a part of his trade, business or occupation” and contracts with a subcontractor for part of it. Subsection B applies when a contractor contracts to do work for another person “which work or undertaking is not a part of the trade, business or occupation of such other person” and contracts with a subcontractor for part of it. Under either, the owner or contractor “shall be liable to pay to any worker employed in the work any compensation under this title which he would have been liable to pay if” the worker had been immediately employed by him, and subsection C gives the same liability for work passed down to a further subcontractor. The Virginia page carries the remainder. In Arizona and Virginia alike, an insulation contractor who hires out part of a job reads the statute’s conditions against how the job is actually run.

Statutes that ask for paper before the sub starts

Rhode Island puts a paper duty on the general contractor. The Rhode Island general-laws provision on subcontractor documentation covers a general contractor and a construction manager alike, and each “shall at all times require written documentation evidencing that the subcontractor carries workers’ compensation insurance with no indebtedness for its employees for the term of the contract”, or that the sub is an independent contractor under another section of the chapter. If the documentation is not obtained from the subcontractor, the party that failed “shall be deemed to be the employer”. A later subsection of the provision limits it to a general contractor, subcontractor or construction manager already subject, as an employer, to the state’s workers’ compensation chapters. See the Rhode Island page.

Indiana names the document. Under the Indiana Code provision on contractors and their subcontractors, a contractor who lets part of its work to a sub that is subject to the compensation provisions “without obtaining a certificate from the worker’s compensation board” showing the sub has complied with the sections the statute lists “shall be liable to the same extent as such subcontractor for the payment of compensation”. Indiana also has an independent contractor path: the Indiana Worker’s Compensation Board’s compliance page states that an independent contractor that has not made the election it describes “must file a statement with the department of state revenue” and “obtain a certificate of exemption”. Our Indiana page carries the state’s rule for employers.

Massachusetts’ Department of Industrial Accidents puts the general contractor’s side in plain terms: “General contractors have legitimate concerns about whether subcontractors have workers’ compensation insurance as they can be held liable for claims against them by a subcontractor or their employees.” It adds, “Therefore, subcontractors may find the general contractor requires them to provide proof of workers’ compensation coverage”. The Massachusetts page links the state’s sources.

Premium that follows the contract down the line

Ohio and Washington are states with a state fund, and each ties premium to the contract. The Ohio Revised Code provision on employer premium says “A private employer who has contracted with a subcontractor is liable for the unpaid premium due from any subcontractor with respect to that part of the payroll of the subcontractor that is for work performed pursuant to the contract with the employer.” That sentence reaches the sub’s unpaid premium on the contracted payroll. The Ohio page explains the state-fund system.

Washington’s Revised Code provision on contractors and subcontractors holds the party that lets a contract “responsible primarily and directly for all premiums upon the work”, and then lists a safe harbor. A contractor registered under the state’s contractor chapter, or licensed under its plumbing or electrical chapters, “is not responsible for any premiums upon the work of any subcontractor if” the listed conditions are met. Among them: “The subcontractor has an industrial insurance account in good standing with the department or is a self-insurer.” The Washington page carries the state-fund rule.

Texas: coverage by election, with public work apart

Texas starts from choice. The Texas Labor Code provision on election says “Except for public employers and as otherwise provided by law, an employer may elect to obtain workers’ compensation insurance coverage.” Public projects are the exception the Texas page sets out. Under the Labor Code provision on public projects, a governmental entity contracting for building or construction work “shall require the contractor to certify in writing that the contractor provides workers’ compensation insurance coverage for each employee of the contractor employed on the public project.”

Read those provisions for what they say. Coverage is the employer’s election unless the law provides otherwise, and on public building or construction work the contractor certifies coverage in writing. What a prime contract asks of its subs is written in that contract, so the Texas page and the contract’s insurance clause belong on the same desk.

The proof to collect from a sub

The sources above name proof in different words. Rhode Island says “written documentation”, Indiana says a certificate from the board, and the Minnesota Workers’ Compensation Insurance Association’s Basic Manual asks that the subcontractor “must furnish satisfactory evidence that the subcontractor has workers’ compensation insurance in force covering the work performed for the contractor”. The manual lists the documents that may be used: “Certificate of insurance for the subcontractor’s workers’ compensation policy” and “Copy of the subcontractor’s workers’ compensation policy”.

The details differ across those words: Minnesota’s manual asks for evidence of coverage in force for the work performed, Rhode Island’s statute for documentation that the sub carries coverage across the contract’s term, and Indiana’s for the board’s certificate that the sub has complied. Ask each sub for proof that fits, and keep a copy. The request that runs the other way, from a general contractor to you, has its own post: Certificate of Insurance for Subcontractors.

How an uninsured sub reaches the payroll audit

The premium side sits in the rating bureaus’ manuals. The Massachusetts bureau’s manual refers to the Massachusetts workers’ compensation chapter for the circumstances in which a contractor answers for an uninsured sub’s employees, and says “This statutory responsibility is automatically insured by the Standard Policy”. The manual then says “For each such subcontractor or independent contractor for which such evidence is not furnished, additional premium shall be charged on the policy”. The Minnesota association’s manual says it the same way: for each sub not providing evidence, “additional premium must be charged on the contractor’s policy for the uninsured subcontractor’s employees”.

The audit is the step that sets the final figure. The Massachusetts manual says “Final earned premium for the policy must be determined on actual payroll as determined by the carrier at audit, instead of on estimated payroll or other premium basis.” Read together, those rules put the charge for an uninsured sub on the contractor’s policy, and the audit is where the final premium is set.

Real-World Scenario: An insulation contractor hires a sub crew for a blown-in attic retrofit, takes the sub’s word that it is covered, and files no proof. A sub’s installer is hurt on the job, and the sub has no policy. Where the state’s statute reaches the hiring contractor, as the Arizona, Virginia and Indiana provisions above can when their conditions are met, the injured worker’s claim can come to the contractor. When the premium is figured, a bureau rule like the Massachusetts or Minnesota manual’s adds premium to the contractor’s own policy for the sub’s payroll.

How the manuals build the payroll charged for an uninsured sub

The manuals describe how the payroll is built. The Massachusetts manual says “The contractor shall provide a complete payroll record of the employees of each uninsured subcontractor or uninsured independent contractor.” Then “Premium on such payroll shall be based on the classifications which would have applied” had the sub’s employees been the contractor’s. Where the contractor cannot supply payroll, the manual says, “If the contractor does not supply the payroll records of its subcontractor or independent contractor, the full subcontract or independent contract price of the work performed” during the policy period “shall be established as the payroll of the subcontractor’s or independent contractor’s employees”. Each manual makes an exception where a specific job shows that a definite amount of the contract price is payroll, and in each the payroll then stays subject to a minimum share of the contract price that depends on the kind of job, such as labor only or labor and material.

Minnesota’s manual agrees on classification: “the payroll determined for subcontractors is assigned to the classification that would have applied if the individuals had been employees of the contractor.” Which classification that is for insulation work is the subject of Insulation Class Code for Workers Comp. The Minnesota manual adds that “if an experience modification has been established for the contractor, this experience modification must be applied to the premium developed for the uninsured subcontractor.”

Before the next sub starts work

Begin with the state where the work is done, and read its state page. Then ask each sub, before its crew sets foot on the job, for proof of coverage in the form the state or the prime contract names, covering the work and the term, and keep the copy with the subcontract.

Ask for payroll as well, because the Massachusetts and Minnesota manuals set payroll from the sub’s own payroll records where they exist and from the contract price where they do not, unless the job shows a definite payroll amount, which stays subject to each manual’s minimum share of the contract price for the kind of job. Ask these questions of a sub on a spray foam job and a sub on a fiberglass job alike; the work itself is described on the spray foam page and the fiberglass page.

When you ask for a workers’ compensation quote, say which work goes to subs, in which states, and which subs hand you proof. The state’s statute decides who answers for a hurt worker, and the manuals set how an uninsured sub’s payroll is charged to your policy.

From a subcontracted crew on the job to the payroll audit: what follows when no proof of the sub’s coverage is on file.

A flow diagram. A subcontracted crew does the work, and the hiring contractor asks the sub for proof of its own coverage and keeps it on file. If none comes, a state statute that reaches the hiring contractor can bring a hurt worker’s claim to it, and, under the Massachusetts and Minnesota manuals, the premium figuring asks about the sub’s payroll, using the price of the subcontracted work where complete payroll records are not supplied and the job shows no definite payroll amount; a definite amount stays subject to minimums by kind of job. No figures are shown.

Frequently asked questions

1099 workers comp: does the form a sub is paid on decide who is covered?

The payment form is not the test in the sources cited here. The IRS page on independent contractors is about how to treat payments for tax, and the Department of Labor’s misclassification page states its test “under the FLSA”. For a worker injured at work, the Department’s workers’ compensation page sends private-company employees to their state board. States then use their own words: Arizona’s statute, for instance, makes a contractor’s and subcontractor’s employees “employees of the original employer” when its conditions are met.

1099 workers comp exemption: can an independent contractor be exempt from coverage?

Where a state allows an exemption, through that state’s own process. The Indiana Worker’s Compensation Board’s compliance page states that an independent contractor that has not made the election it describes “must file a statement with the department of state revenue” and “obtain a certificate of exemption”. A contractor in Indiana that lets part of its work to a sub that is subject to the compensation provisions without obtaining the board’s certificate of the sub’s compliance is liable to the same extent as the sub for the payment of compensation and medical and burial expenses on account of the injury or death of any employee of the sub in the work covered by the subcontract. Check your state’s page before treating an exemption as covering your crew.

Do 1099 employees need workers comp where a statute reaches the hiring contractor?

Virginia’s statute has two triggers: a person who undertakes work “which is a part of his trade, business or occupation” and subcontracts part of it, and a contractor who takes on work for another person that is not part of that other person’s trade, business or occupation and subcontracts part of it. In either case the owner or contractor “shall be liable to pay to any worker employed in the work any compensation under this title which he would have been liable to pay if” the worker had been immediately employed by him. Rhode Island’s statute, where the state’s compensation chapters already make the contractor an employer, says the party without written documentation from the sub “shall be deemed to be the employer”. Those provisions do not ask about the sub’s tax form.

Do 1099 employees need workers comp in Massachusetts? What the state tells general contractors

Massachusetts’ Department of Industrial Accidents says general contractors “can be held liable for claims against them by a subcontractor or their employees”, so subcontractors “may find the general contractor requires them to provide proof of workers’ compensation coverage”. The state’s rating bureau adds the premium side: for each sub without evidence of coverage, “additional premium shall be charged on the policy” that insures the contractor. See the Massachusetts page for the statute.

Subcontractor workers comp waiver form Texas: what does Texas law say about subs?

The Texas provisions on our Texas page speak to coverage by election and to public work. Labor Code provision on election says an employer “may elect to obtain workers’ compensation insurance coverage”, and its provision on public projects has a governmental entity require a building or construction contractor to certify coverage in writing “for each employee of the contractor employed on the public project”. Those provisions are not a waiver form. For a private job, read the prime contract’s insurance clause for what it asks of subs.

Subcontractor without workers compensation insurance: who answers when the sub’s worker is hurt?

The answer is each state’s. In Indiana, a contractor that hands part of its work to a sub that is subject to the compensation provisions, without the board’s certificate, “shall be liable to the same extent as such subcontractor for the payment of compensation”. Under Arizona’s statute, when its control and trade conditions are met, the subcontractor’s employees are employees of the original employer. Read the state’s page and the subcontract’s insurance clause before the sub starts.

Insurance audit uninsured subcontractors: what does the audit add to the contractor’s policy?

Under the Minnesota rating association’s Basic Manual, for each subcontractor not providing evidence of coverage “additional premium must be charged on the contractor’s policy for the uninsured subcontractor’s employees”. The Massachusetts bureau’s manual has the same shape: where evidence is not furnished, “additional premium shall be charged on the policy”, on the classifications that would apply if the sub’s employees were the contractor’s.