Insulation company marketing should rest on referral partners and reviews you ask every customer for. The Federal Trade Commission’s R-value rule sets what a home insulation ad aimed at consumers must say about R-value, price and savings, its reviews rule governs how a business gathers and shows reviews, and a Massachusetts contractor’s home improvement ad must carry the registration number.
Where insulation leads come from before any ad runs
Start with the lists a homeowner is told to check. ENERGY STAR’s attic insulation page tells homeowners “Start by checking with your local gas or electric utility. They may offer incentives to do the work and provide pre-screened lists of licensed and insured contractors on their websites.” It also lists “ENERGY STAR Home Upgrade Service Providers”.
Call your gas and electric utilities and ask whether they keep a contractor list, what they ask of the contractors on it, and which rebate programs they run.
Referral partners and what they need from you
Bring each partner the paperwork its work already calls for. For a builder that sells new homes, the R-value rule says “If you are a new home seller, you must put the following information in every sales contract: The type, thickness, and R-value of the insulation that will be installed in each part of the house.” The rule has an exception: if the buyer signs before the seller knows the insulation type, or the contract changes, the seller can give a receipt with that information as soon as it knows.
The rule tells installers “Before customers agree to buy insulation from you, you must show them the fact sheet(s) for the type(s) of insulation they want.”
For a general contractor, have the insurance answer ready before the bid goes out. The Indiana Department of Insurance says “Certificates generally serve only as an informational summary of insurance in lieu of an actual copy of an insurance policy and should not be used to amend, extend, or alter policy terms.” Our general liability page explains what the policy behind that certificate answers for.
Real-World Scenario: An energy auditor sends a small attic contractor a referral, and the owner wants to thank the auditor with a gift card and put the homeowner’s glowing review on the website. Before anything goes live he sends the same review request to every recent customer, asks the auditor to mention the referral arrangement in any public praise, and checks that the flyer he is drafting names the type and thickness behind every R-value it mentions.
The R-value rule’s duties for an insulation ad
An R-value, a price or a comparison in an ad brings disclosures under the FTC’s R-value rule. The rule says the home insulation industry “includes manufacturers, distributors, franchisors, installers, retailers, utility companies, and trade associations. Advertisers and advertising agencies are also covered.”
For an R-value, “If your ad gives an R-value, you must give the type of insulation and the thickness needed to get that R-value.”, along with the statement “The higher the R-value, the greater the insulating power. Ask your seller for the fact sheet on R-values.” For a price, “If your ad gives a price, you must give the type of insulation, the R-value at a specific thickness, the statement explaining R-values in paragraph (a) of this section, and the coverage area for that thickness.”, though “If you give the price per square foot, you do not have to give the coverage area.” And “If your ad compares one type of insulation to another, the comparison must be based on the same coverage areas.”
Television and radio ads, and space-constrained online ads, have a limited exception: “The affirmative disclosure requirements in this section do not apply to television or radio advertisements or to space-constrained advertisements.”
Savings, per-inch, government and tax claims
A promise of lower bills needs support you can produce. The rule says “If you say or imply in your ads, labels, or other promotional materials that insulation can cut fuel bills or fuel use, you must have a reasonable basis for the claim.” Outside television, radio and space-constrained ads, the ad must also carry “Savings vary. Find out why in the seller’s fact sheet on R-values. Higher R-values mean greater insulating power.”
The rule limits a non-manufacturer’s liability for the reasonable-basis duty: “If you are not a manufacturer, you are liable only if you know or should know that the manufacturer does not have a reasonable basis for the claim.”
Check any per-inch claim before it runs. The rule tells sellers, in promotional materials, “do not give the R-value for one inch” of a product, and allows it “if actual test results prove that the R-values per inch of your product does not drop as it gets thicker.” If foam is your product, the spray foam insurance page is where the policy questions sit.
Government and tax lines must be true. The rule says “Do not say or imply that a government agency uses, certifies, recommends, or otherwise favors your product unless it is true.” ENERGY STAR points homeowners to “a list of ENERGY STAR certified insulation products”, so check that list for the product before an ad uses the name. On tax claims, “Do not say or imply that your product qualifies for a tax benefit unless it is true.”
Asking for reviews the FTC way
Ask every customer, the same way, and reward none of them for praise. The FTC’s consumer reviews rule makes it an unfair or deceptive practice for a business “to provide compensation or other incentives in exchange for, or conditioned expressly or by implication on, the writing or creation of consumer reviews expressing a particular sentiment, whether positive or negative”.
In an example in the FTC’s Endorsement Guides, a marketer that invites only purchasers who gave very positive feedback to post reviews engages in a practice that “may be an unfair or deceptive practice if it results in the posted reviews being substantially more positive than if the marketer had not engaged in the practice.” Had it “simply invited all recent purchasers to provide feedback on third-party websites, the solicitation would not have been unfair or deceptive, even if it had expressed its hope for positive reviews.”
The reviews rule bars a business from materially misrepresenting, in the part of its website or platform that receives and displays consumer reviews, that the reviews shown “represent most or all the reviews submitted to the website or platform when reviews are being suppressed” for their ratings or negative sentiment. The Guides give an example of a critic’s review excerpted in a producer’s ad: “If the excerpt alters or quotes from the text of the review in a way that does not fairly reflect its substance, the advertisement would be deceptive because it distorts the endorser’s opinion.” Quote a customer’s review in an ad with the same care.
Reviews from owners, crews, relatives and paid helpers
A review written by an officer or manager of the business has to say so. The reviews rule makes it a violation “for an officer or manager of a business to write or create a consumer review or consumer testimonial about the business or one of the products or services it sells that fails to have a clear and conspicuous disclosure of the officer’s or manager’s material relationship to the business, unless, in the case of a consumer testimonial, the relationship is otherwise clear to the audience”, and it says “Officers include owners, executives, and managing members of a business.”
If you ask your employees, agents or their immediate relatives for reviews, our advice is to tell them in writing to disclose the relationship. Under the same rule, an officer or manager who solicits reviews from their own immediate relatives, or employees and agents or those people’s immediate relatives, violates it when the solicitation results in a review “without a disclosure of the reviewer’s material relationship to the business” and any of the rule’s listed conditions is met, including that the officer or manager “Did not instruct that prospective reviewers disclose clearly and conspicuously their relationship to the business”. That provision does not reach generalized solicitations to purchasers to post reviews about their experiences.
A referral partner you pay or give gifts to can have a material connection with you, and the FTC’s Endorsement Guides, its guidance on how the FTC Act applies to endorsements, say a connection must be disclosed when it “is not reasonably expected by the audience”. The Guides say “Material connections can include a business, family, or personal relationship.” and that they can include “monetary payment or the provision of free or discounted products”. A referral fee to an auditor who also praises your work in public is that kind of connection.
A site or organization you control must not pose as an independent judge of a category of businesses: the reviews rule bars a business from materially misrepresenting “that a website, organization, or entity that it controls, owns, or operates provides independent reviews or opinions, other than consumer reviews, about a category of businesses, products, or services including the business or one or more of the products or services it sells”.
Contract terms that gag a customer’s review
Leave review restrictions out of your proposal and contract forms. Under the Consumer Review Fairness Act, a provision of a form contract (“a contract with standardized terms” that is “imposed on an individual without a meaningful opportunity for such individual to negotiate the standardized terms”) is void, except as the Act provides, if it “prohibits or restricts the ability of an individual who is a party to the form contract to engage in a covered communication” or “imposes a penalty or fee against an individual who is a party to the form contract for engaging in a covered communication”. Offering such a term is itself a violation: “It shall be unlawful for a person to offer a form contract containing a provision described as void in subsection (b).”
Registration numbers and licensing words in an ad
A state or city can set what an ad must carry. Massachusetts is the plainest case. Its home improvement contractor law prohibits a contractor from “publishing, directly or indirectly, any advertisement relating to home construction or home improvements which does not contain the contractor’s or subcontractor’s certificate of registration number”. The Massachusetts page sets out who must register.
Elsewhere, advertising decides whether a small-job exemption holds. Oregon’s contractor statute exempts a person whose contracts on a structure or project stay under the aggregate price the statute sets and whose work “is of a casual, minor or inconsequential nature”, but that exemption “does not apply to a person who advertises or puts out any sign or card or other device that might indicate to the public that the person is a contractor.” See the Oregon page. New Mexico’s contractor licensing statute conditions its small-job exclusion, among other things, on “the individual does not advertise or maintain a sign, card or other device which would indicate to the public that he is qualified to engage in the business of contracting”; the New Mexico page has the rest.
Maine’s insulation contractors chapter is a written-contract law and not a license: it requires a written contract when a person installs insulation in an existing residence for compensation, and its exemption reaches a person “not primarily engaged in the business of installing insulation” who also “does not advertise as, solicit as or present as a person who installs insulation”. The section sets the “not primarily engaged” test as a calendar year’s gross receipts from insulation work, which may not go over its labor limit or its materials limit, as the Maine page explains. City rules can reach advertising too: Cheyenne’s Contractor Licensing Regulations say “No person may perform work, services or advertising related to the construction” of a building or structure in the City “without having obtained the contractor and building trade licenses required by the Ordinances and the City of Cheyenne Contractor Licensing Regulations.” The Wyoming page covers Cheyenne.
Insurance words and what a customer will check
An insurance line in an ad is a claim like any other. The FTC Act says “Unfair methods of competition in or affecting commerce, and unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce, are hereby declared unlawful.” Print the coverage you carry today, and keep the certificate ready for the homeowner or general contractor who asks to see it.
Whether to advertise as bonded and insured is a question of its own, and our bond guide takes it up, including a state law on advertising it. For the policies themselves, start at the business insurance page, and see the workers’ compensation page for the crew. If an ad claims coverage you do not yet hold, ask for that coverage on the quote form.