Cost Guides

Contractor Insurance Cost for Insulation Crews in New York

A gloved hand sealing the gap between a window frame and a wall with a caulk gun

Contractor insurance cost in New York includes a workers’ compensation premium built under the Rating Board’s Manual. For an insulation crew, the sources below describe a weekly payroll cap for listed construction classes, territories set by jobsite, an uninsured subcontractor’s effect on a general contractor’s policy, and the audit. No price is given here.

Compulsory coverage, with a state-run fund beside the private carriers

Workers’ Compensation Law § 2 defines an employer, except where the chapter says otherwise, as a “person, partnership, association, corporation” that has persons in employment, and § 10 directs employers subject to the chapter, with the exceptions it provides, to “secure compensation to his employees”. The state’s workers’ compensation agency says on its coverage page that “Virtually all employers” in the state must provide this coverage for their employees. Licensing and code context for New York sits on the state page.

Section 50 lists the ways an employer may secure that compensation, among them insuring in the state fund, insuring with an authorized insurer, or showing the chair that it can pay the compensation itself. Section 76 continues a fund the statute names “the state insurance fund” within the department of labor, that covers employers’ liability for employee injuries and deaths. Section 89 provides that the fund’s premiums are “fixed at the lowest possible rates consistent with the maintenance of a solvent fund and of reasonable reserves and surplus.” The workers’ compensation coverage page describes the policy itself.

From an approved loss cost to the rate printed on the policy

The Rating Board’s Manual builds a carrier’s workers’ compensation rate from a loss cost. The New York Compensation Insurance Rating Board says it is “licensed as the official rate service organization”. For workers’ compensation insurance, Insurance Law § 2304 defines a loss cost as “that portion of a rate intended to represent the anticipated costs of claim payments and loss adjustment expenses associated with such claim payments”, and leaves out provisions for acquisition costs, overhead, taxes and profit.

The Manual’s Rule VI says the carrier’s approved rate for a classification “is derived by multiplying the approved loss cost by” a carrier-specific factor that the Manual abbreviates LCM and the Superintendent of Financial Services approves. Each carrier “must separately file its LCM with the Superintendent” for approval. Because each carrier files its own factor, the Manual’s approved rate for a classification is specific to that carrier.

The Manual figures the premium for a classification from the payroll basis and that rate. It adds an expense constant, a premium charge that “applies to every policy”, and sets a carrier minimum premium. To find the classification that fits a crew, start with the class code guide.

The weekly payroll cap on New York construction classes

New York caps the payroll that counts for premium for construction classification employers. For premiums in the state fund, Workers’ Compensation Law § 89 defines a construction classification as employments classified under each of Labor Law §§ 220, 240 and 241, and Insurance Law § 2304 applies the same test to the payroll basis for those employments. Each statute carves out “the construction of one or two family residential housing”. Under the Manual’s Rule V, the actual weekly payroll per employee counts, up to the greater of the current New York payroll limitation value or the weekly wage on which the maximum weekly benefit is based. For this rule the Manual states that “Construction, for purposes of this Rule, includes new construction, as well as remodeling, repairs, and maintenance of existing structures.”

The Manual ties the cap to records. It says that “If an employer does not provide sufficient employee payroll records necessary to segregate residential from commercial employments, no payroll limitation shall apply.”

Real-World Scenario: A Long Island insulation contractor keeps a payroll summary for the year. An attic retrofit on a house within the residential carve-out and a retrofit on a commercial building appear on it together, with crew hours blended. At audit the records decide it. Because the summary does not separate them, the Manual’s sentence on insufficient records governs, and, if the crew’s classification is one the Manual lists for the cap, the cap the crew would have kept may not apply.

Territory differentials follow the jobsite

For employments classified under each of Labor Law §§ 220, 240 and 241, Insurance Law § 2304 has the loss costs adjusted to reflect the payroll limitations as they separately affect rates for work actually performed in separate geographic territories: the counties of the Bronx, Kings, New York, Queens and Richmond; Dutchess, Nassau, Orange, Putnam, Rockland, Suffolk and Westchester; and all other counties within the state. In the Manual, Rule VI says a differential “shall be applied to each portion of the manual premium corresponding to the geographic territory in which work has actually been performed”, and adds that territory differentials are not applied to premiums from the residential housing that Rule V describes.

For payroll limitation purposes, Rule V assigns an employee’s weekly earnings “to the territory in which the majority of the week’s work was performed.” For an employer whose employees work in different geographic territories and who cannot provide payroll records that identify payroll by territory, the same rule sends all payroll to “the territory with the next highest premium differential to that of the employer’s home office or New York base of operations.” Where an investigation of a specific job shows it was performed in the territory with the highest premium differential, the rule sends all payroll to that territory instead.

Experience rating, safety credits and the optional schedule adjustment

The Rating Board’s experience rating plan applies on a mandatory basis to risks that meet the plan’s eligibility requirements. Under it, a modification is “based on individual employer payroll and loss records, which may result in an increase, decrease, or no change in premium.” The plan states that “No loss is excluded from the experience of a risk even if the employer was not responsible for the accident that caused such loss.”

Programs sit on top. The Manual says the Department of Labor administers a safety incentive program that grants premium credits as set by the state’s insurance regulator, and lists credits for an employer with an approved safety incentive, drug and alcohol prevention, or return to work program that meets the program’s requirements. Its construction classification premium adjustment program provides a premium credit for a policy that has a stated amount of New York subject premium, contains a construction classification the Manual lists for the program, and satisfies the hourly wage requirement; policies under a retrospective rating plan or a large deductible program are not eligible.

The Manual’s schedule rating plan is “applied on an optional basis by the carrier”, for policies that meet an annual manual premium minimum, and the Manual says such plans “should not include debits or credits to reflect past loss experience.”

An uninsured subcontractor lands on the general contractor’s policy

Workers’ Compensation Law § 56 makes a contractor whose contract involves a hazardous employment, and who subcontracts part of the work, liable for compensation to a subcontractor’s injured employee for injury arising out of that hazardous employment, unless the subcontractor “has secured compensation therefor as provided in this chapter.” The Manual’s Rule VIII addresses uninsured subcontractors in the premium. The contractor must give its carrier satisfactory evidence that the subcontractor’s workers’ compensation insurance was in force. Where it cannot, the Manual says the premium on the contractor’s policy is figured by “assigning the appropriate classification to the entire payroll expended by the subcontractor for the subcontracted work.”

If a contractor does not hand over the subcontractor’s payroll records, Rule VIII fixes a share of the subcontract price as payroll, and which share depends on whether the work is labor only, labor and material, or mobile equipment with operators. An investigation of a specific job that discloses a definite payroll amount within the price replaces that share. The agency’s coverage page says: “In many instances, individuals alleged to be subcontractors have been determined by the Board, acting in its adjudicatory capacity, to be employees when such individuals have been injured and have filed claims against the general contractor.” As a result, it says, “insurance carriers often assess general contractors premiums for coverage of all” subcontractors on a job site “unless the subcontractors furnish proof that they have their own workers’ compensation insurance policy.” It adds that “general contractors routinely require that subcontractors provide proof of their own workers’ compensation coverage in order to co-work on the job.”

Employment status is a related question. On the same page the agency says that, for workers’ compensation, a worker who is hurt doing a contractor’s work is presumed to be that contractor’s employee under New York’s Fair Play Act for construction, subject to the Act’s independent contractor test. Our guides to independent contractor workers’ comp and the certificate of insurance for subcontractors show how that plays out in the paperwork.

The audit, and opinions of the former Insurance Department

Rule VI of the Manual says the carrier “shall conduct a physical audit, whether at the employer’s location or at a remote site, of the employer’s records to determine the premium”, on a schedule that depends on the size of the employer’s annual premium; where clearly impracticable, an audit may be waived and a signed payroll statement from the employer may be accepted. The auditor completes the report “directly from the books of account and original payroll records”, and if the books and the records “were revised for auditing purposes, the employer is not entitled to any exclusions of remuneration for the policy period(s) being audited.” Rule V excludes the extra pay for overtime from the remuneration on which premium is computed “provided the employer’s books and records are maintained to show overtime pay separately by employee and in summary by classification.”

A general liability policy can be auditable too. The Department of Financial Services posts opinions of the former Insurance Department’s Office of General Counsel, each written for the Insurance Law as it then read; check the current text of the sections they name. The June opinion, an informal opinion issued in the middle of the first decade of this century, concludes under Insurance Law § 3426 that “an insurer may increase the premium of a current policy based upon an audit that reflects the current risk”, and that the current policy may be canceled for nonpayment of that additional premium, but that an insurer “may not cancel a current policy for nonpayment of premium that represents a recovery of premiums due to the insurer for prior years in which the insurer undercharged the insured.” The July opinion, issued in July of the next year, deals with a general liability policy that is “auditable based on either the insured’s annual sales or estimated payroll”; for an authorized insurer, it says whether a percentage-based minimum earned premium is acceptable depends on the insurer’s ability to prove that the minimum earned premium filed equals the cost associated with issuing the policy. The general liability coverage page describes the policy.

Proof for public offices, local conditions and vehicles

Workers’ Compensation Law § 57 bars the head of a state or municipal department, board, commission or office from issuing a permit, or entering into a contract, for work involving employees in hazardous employment unless proof subscribed by an insurance carrier, in the form the chair finds satisfactory, shows that “compensation for all employees has been secured”.

Local offices can add conditions the policy has to meet, and our license guide separates what the state requires from what localities add. The home improvement registration form of Putnam County asks that the county be listed as the additional insured, and the insurance sheet of the City of Albany says its city code sets specific insurance requirements to be met with its buildings office before permits issue. Insurance Law § 502 bars a person or governmental entity from willfully requiring, as a condition of awarding or performing a contract for work, a certificate of insurance for personal injury or property damage liability coverage unless the certificate is on the insurer’s own form or on a standard form the superintendent has approved. Subsection (b) does not prohibit minimum insurance requirements, coverage limits, terms or other conditions in the solicitation of bids as part of a competitive process, and subsection (c) says a certificate “shall not amend, extend, or alter the coverage provided by the insurance policy”.

Vehicles carry their own line. Vehicle and Traffic Law § 312 says no motor vehicle may be registered in New York unless the application is accompanied by proof of financial security, evidenced by proof of insurance or evidence of a bond, a deposit or qualification as a self-insurer. Policy terms for vehicles are on the commercial auto page. Those trades have spray foam and fiberglass pages, the Texas cost guide speaks to that state, and the bond guide speaks to surety questions. The quote page is there once the payroll split, subcontractor certificates and vehicle list are in hand.

How a New York insulation crew’s payroll becomes a workers’ compensation premium, from the approved loss cost to the audit.

A flow showing how a New York insulation crew’s payroll becomes a workers’ compensation premium. It starts with the loss cost the Rating Board promulgates and the Superintendent of Financial Services approves, moves to the carrier’s own filed factor and the resulting rate, then to the weekly payroll cap that applies to the construction classes the Manual lists, outside the residential housing it describes, then to the territory where the work was done, then to the experience modification and program credits, and ends with the carrier’s audit of the employer’s payroll records. No figures are shown.

Premium depends on payroll, the materials you spray or blow, subcontracted work, vehicles and rigs, tool and equipment values, and the states you work in. We do not publish typical rates because there is no such thing as a typical insulation contractor.

Frequently asked questions

Contractor insurance cost New York: what drives the premium for an insulation crew?

Payroll, as the state’s rating system treats it. The Rating Board’s Manual builds a carrier’s approved rate from an approved loss cost and the carrier’s own filed factor, and the premium for a classification comes from that rate and the payroll basis. For the construction classes the statute and the Manual name, weekly payroll is capped per employee, outside the residential housing they describe. Experience rating, the territory of the work and the audit then shape the result.

Contractor insurance NY cost: does where the crew works in the state change it?

For employments classified under each of Labor Law §§ 220, 240 and 241, Insurance Law § 2304 has loss costs adjusted for the payroll limitation as it affects rates for work performed in separate geographic territories. For payroll limitation purposes, the Manual assigns an employee’s weekly earnings “to the territory in which the majority of the week’s work was performed.” Its Rule VI applies no territory differential to premium from the residential housing that Rule V describes.

General liability insurance cost New York: can the premium change after the policy year?

An informal opinion of the former Insurance Department’s Office of General Counsel, issued in the middle of the first decade of this century and posted by the state’s insurance regulator, says “an insurer may increase the premium of a current policy based upon an audit that reflects the current risk”. It adds that an insurer may not cancel a current policy for nonpayment of premium that recovers prior years’ undercharges. The opinion reads Insurance Law § 3426 as it stood then.

Does New York require workers comp for independent contractors on an insulation job?

The state’s workers’ compensation agency says that under New York’s Fair Play Act for construction a worker who is hurt doing a contractor’s work is presumed to be that contractor’s employee for workers’ compensation, subject to the Act’s independent contractor test. Workers’ Compensation Law § 56 separately makes a contractor whose contract involves a hazardous employment liable to a subcontractor’s injured employee unless the subcontractor has secured compensation.

General contractor insurance cost: how does an uninsured subcontractor affect a New York policy?

The Rating Board’s Manual, in its Rule VIII, says the contractor must give its carrier satisfactory evidence that a subcontractor had workers’ compensation insurance in force. For a subcontractor with no such evidence, the premium on the contractor’s policy is computed by assigning the appropriate classification to the entire payroll the subcontractor spent on the work. Without the subcontractor’s payroll records from the contractor, a share of the subcontract price counts as payroll.

Contractor insurance rates in New York: who approves them?

In the Manual, the Rating Board promulgates the loss costs and the Superintendent of Financial Services approves them. Each carrier must separately file its own factor, which the Manual abbreviates LCM, with the Superintendent for approval, so the approved rate is specific to each carrier. Workers’ Compensation Law § 89 governs how employments in the state insurance fund are grouped and how that fund’s premiums are fixed.

Who is exempt from workers compensation in New York if I run an insulation business alone?

For a for-profit business, the state’s workers’ compensation agency says a sole proprietor without employees need not carry coverage, though the owner may choose to be covered. Partnerships, LLCs and LLPs without employees are in the same position, it says. A general contractor can still insist on a policy: the agency says this results in “many sole proprietors, partnerships, and one or two-person owned corporations with no employees” being required to buy a policy to work for a particular general contractor.

Insulation contractor insurance cost New York: why do residential and commercial payroll need separate records?

Because the Manual ties the payroll cap to that split. Its rule says “If an employer does not provide sufficient employee payroll records necessary to segregate residential from commercial employments, no payroll limitation shall apply.” The statute excludes the construction of the residential housing it describes from the cap, so a crew that works on residential and commercial jobs should keep weekly payroll by employee and by job type from the start of the policy period.